Exploring the Best Wineries in Fish Creek and Egg Harbor

Exploring the Best Wineries in Fish Creek and Egg Harbor

  • Arbor Crowne Properties
  • 05/8/25

If you find yourself enchanted by the scenic beauty and charm of Door County, Wisconsin, a wine tour through Fish Creek and Sister Bay should undoubtedly be on your itinerary. Known for their rolling vineyards, award-winning wines, and welcoming atmospheres, these destinations offer something for every oenophile.

Whether you're a seasoned wine connoisseur or just someone who enjoys a casual tasting, the wineries in this area are sure to impress. Let's explore some of the top recommended wineries that deserve a spot on your list.

Top Recommended Wineries

Lautenbach's Orchard Country Winery & Market

Location: 9197 WI-42, Fish Creek
Features: 100-acre estate, 50 award-winning wines and hard ciders
Offers: Wine tastings, wine garden, rustic cupola room

Lautenbach's Orchard Country Winery & Market is a premier destination for wine lovers visiting Fish Creek. This sprawling 100-acre estate has been a staple in the community, producing over 50 award-winning wines and hard ciders. The estate is not just about wine; it’s an immersive experience. Stroll through the vineyards, enjoy tastings in their rustic cupola room, or relax in the picturesque wine garden. Lautenbach's is known for its friendly staff and laid-back atmosphere, making it a perfect stop for families and couples alike.

One of the highlights of visiting Lautenbach’s is their wide variety of wines, ranging from rich reds to crisp whites and fruit-forward wines. Their cherry wines are particularly popular, reflecting the region's famed cherry orchards. Don’t miss out on their hard ciders, which offer a refreshing alternative to wine on a warm summer day.

Door Peninsula Winery

Location: Carlsville (near Egg Harbor)
Established: 1974
Specialties: 60+ wines and ciders, famous for fruit wines

A short drive from Fish Creek, Door Peninsula Winery is one of the most iconic wineries in the region. Established in 1974, it has grown to become one of Wisconsin's largest wineries, boasting over 60 different wines and ciders. Door Peninsula Winery is especially famous for its fruit wines, which capture the essence of local produce like cherries, apples, and blackberries.

Visitors can indulge in tastings of a diverse selection, from dry reds to sweet dessert wines. The knowledgeable staff is always eager to guide you through their offerings, ensuring you find the perfect bottle to take home. Beyond the wine, the winery itself is a historic building, adding to the overall charm of the experience.

Simon Creek Vineyard & Winery

Location: Near Carlsville
Highlights: Over 200 medal-winning wines
Notable Wines: Untouchable Red, Door County Cherry Wine

Simon Creek Vineyard & Winery is another gem near Carlsville that wine enthusiasts should not overlook. Known for producing over 200 medal-winning wines, Simon Creek has built a strong reputation for quality and consistency. Their wines are crafted with precision, and their Untouchable Red and Door County Cherry Wine are perennial favorites.

The winery offers tours and tastings in a peaceful setting, making it an ideal place to unwind and savor the flavors of Door County. Many visitors appreciate the serene environment, as the vineyard provides scenic views that enhance the tasting experience. Simon Creek embodies the essence of local winemaking with a blend of tradition and innovation.

Forgotten Fire Winery

Offers: Wine, hard ciders, and beers
Tasting: 7 wine samples for $4, including souvenir glass

For those looking for a unique experience, Forgotten Fire Winery offers an array of wines, hard ciders, and beers, making it a versatile stop. Their tasting room provides a relaxed atmosphere where guests can sample seven wines for just $4, and each tasting comes with a souvenir glass. This affordable and enjoyable experience allows visitors to explore a wide variety of flavors without breaking the bank.

Forgotten Fire is known for its approachable and friendly environment, making it a great place to start if you are new to wine tasting. The staff are welcoming and knowledgeable, ensuring that everyone leaves with a greater appreciation for the craft of winemaking.

Stone's Throw Winery

Location: Baileys Harbor
Experience: 23+ years in wine production

Stone's Throw Winery, located in Baileys Harbor, is a must-visit for those seeking a more intimate and sophisticated wine experience. With over 23 years of wine production, Stone's Throw takes pride in crafting wines using traditional methods and high-quality grapes. This winery offers a blend of Old World techniques and New World creativity, resulting in unique and memorable wines.

Guests can enjoy tastings in their elegant tasting room or relax outdoors with a glass of wine in hand. Stone's Throw also hosts various events throughout the year, making it a dynamic spot to visit, no matter the season.

Additional Wineries to Explore

Beyond the top-recommended wineries, Door County is home to several other notable vineyards and wineries that are worth exploring:

  • Red Oak Winery
  • Harbor Ridge Winery
Each of these wineries offers its own unique charm and selection of wines, adding depth to the wine trail experience in Door County.

Visitor Tips

  • Take the Door County Wine Trail: One of the best ways to experience the region's wineries is by following the Door County Wine Trail. This self-guided tour connects the top wineries in the area, allowing you to explore at your own pace.

  • Best Visiting Season: While wineries are open year-round, the best time to visit is from May to December, when the vineyards are in full bloom, and the weather is ideal for outdoor tastings.

  • Daily Tastings and Tours: Most wineries offer daily tastings and guided tours, providing insight into the winemaking process and the history of the region.

Make Door County Your Home

After experiencing Fish Creek and Egg Harbor's rich flavors and beautiful landscapes, you might dream of making this wine paradise your permanent home. If so, consider working with Arbor Crowne Properties to find your dream property in Door County. Their local real estate market expertise can help you discover the perfect home or investment property. Visit Arbor Crowne Properties to learn more and take the first step towards owning a piece of this enchanting region.



Work With Us

Arbor Crowne Properties specializes in luxury and waterfront Door County homes. Situated in the idyllic town of Ephraim and operating out of the historic Hillside Waterfront Hotel, Arbor Crowne is perfectly positioned to address your buying and selling needs.

Follow Us on Instagram