Fish Creek Homes for Sale & Real Estate Listings

Search Fish Creek homes for sale with Door County expert, Diane Taillon.

Fish Creek Listings & Sales

For Sale
Sold
Pending
Under Contract
Active Under Contract
Inactive
Unknown
Coming Soon
Pocket Listing

Find Your Dream Fish Creek Home for Sale

Contact Diane

TOP 5 FAQS ABOUT HOMES IN FISH CREEK

Fish Creek, located in the picturesque Door County, Wisconsin, is known for its charming homes and natural beauty. Recent real estate trends in Fish Creek have shown a strong market with consistent demand for both primary and vacation homes. Prices for homes in Fish Creek can vary widely based on factors such as size, location, and proximity to the water. However, the area's popularity as a tourist destination and its year-round appeal contribute to a competitive market.

Fish Creek offers a diverse range of home styles, from cozy cottages to spacious waterfront estates. Many properties feature rustic charm, with wood-beamed ceilings and stone fireplaces, creating a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Waterfront homes along Green Bay or Lake Michigan are particularly sought after, providing stunning views and direct access to the water.

Fish Creek's real estate market tends to be characterized by existing homes and properties, as the area is known for its natural beauty and preservation of its historic character. While there may be occasional new construction or renovations, the majority of homes in Fish Creek are established and designed to blend with the surrounding landscape.

The average home price in Fish Creek can vary depending on the type of property and its location within the area. Generally, you can find homes starting in the mid to upper six-figure range, with waterfront properties and larger estates commanding higher prices. It's essential to work with a local real estate expert who can provide you with current market data and help you navigate the pricing landscape.

Fish Creek's real estate market often experiences a balance between buyers and sellers. The area's popularity as a vacation destination, along with its tranquil year-round appeal, keeps demand steady. Buyers should be prepared to move quickly, especially when prime properties become available. Partnering with a knowledgeable local real estate agent can give you an advantage in navigating the Fish Creek market and finding the right home for your needs.

 

Luxury Homes for Sale in Fish Creek, WI

Discover exclusive waterfront properties and luxury estates in Door County's most prestigious community.

(920) 421-3272

9980 N Water St., Ephraim, WI 54211

[email protected]

View Exclusive Listings
 

Fish Creek, WI Real Estate Market Overview

$725,000
Median Home Price
4.2%
Price Appreciation (YoY)
32
Avg. Days on Market
98%
List-to-Sale Ratio

Fish Creek Community Profile

Demographics

  • Population: 1,072 (year-round)
  • Median Age: 54.3
  • Household Income: $78,450
  • Homeownership Rate: 72%
  • College Graduates: 43%

Lifestyle & Amenities

  • Peninsula State Park: 3,776 acres of natural beauty
  • Marina: 120-slip full-service harbor
  • Cultural: Peninsula Players Theatre, Birch Creek Music
  • Dining: 18 restaurants including White Gull Inn
  • Recreation: Golf, sailing, fishing, hiking

Gibraltar Area Schools

Gibraltar Elementary

3924 Hwy 42, Fish Creek, WI 54212

Rating: 8/10 (GreatSchools)
Grades: PK-5
Students: 215

Gibraltar Secondary

3924 Hwy 42, Fish Creek, WI 54212

Rating: 7/10 (GreatSchools)
Grades: 6-12
Students: 285

Private Options

  • St. Rosalia's School (K-8, Sturgeon Bay)
  • The Prairie School (PK-12, Wind Point)
  • Sturgeon Bay Montessori

Why Choose Diane for Your Fish Creek Home Search?

  • 25+ years Door County real estate experience
  • Top 1% of agents in price per square foot achieved
  • 98% client satisfaction rate
  • Local knowledge: Born and raised in Door County
  • Luxury specialist: Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist
"Diane's knowledge of Fish Creek's unique market helped us find the perfect waterfront property at the right price. Her negotiation skills saved us over $75,000!"
Robert & Susan Thompson
Fish Creek homeowners since 2021

Ready to Find Your Fish Creek Dream Home?

Contact Diane today for a personalized property search and expert market advice.

Fish Creek, WI: Door County's Premier Destination

Living in Fish Creek

Nestled between Green Bay and Lake Michigan, Fish Creek offers the perfect blend of natural beauty and sophisticated amenities. This charming village features:

  • Historic downtown with boutique shopping and fine dining
  • Access to 300+ miles of shoreline
  • Four distinct seasons with vibrant fall colors and snowy winters
  • Thriving arts community with galleries and performance venues
  • Low crime rate and excellent community services

Real Estate Investment Potential

Fish Creek properties have shown consistent appreciation with several unique advantages:

  • Rental income: Premium vacation rentals generate $40,000-$150,000 annually
  • Limited inventory: Only 12% of land available for development
  • Waterfront premium: Appreciates 2-3% faster than inland properties
  • Tax benefits: Wisconsin's favorable property tax structure

Our 2023 market analysis shows Fish Creek luxury homes ($1M+) have appreciated 28% over the past 5 years.

Work With Us

Arbor Crowne Properties specializes in luxury and waterfront Door County homes. Situated in the idyllic town of Fish Creek and operating out of the historic Hillside Waterfront Hotel, Arbor Crowne is perfectly positioned to address your buying and selling needs.