Location: Door County's northernmost village. Zip: 54210. 5 miles north of Sister Bay via WI-42. Approximately 65 miles northeast of Green Bay.
The differentiator: Newport State Park — Wisconsin's only designated Dark Sky Preserve — is immediately adjacent. No other Door County village has this. For buyers who want the most secluded, nature-immersed position on the peninsula, Ellison Bay is the answer.
Distance from Sister Bay: 5 miles north (~8 minutes). Residents access Sister Bay's full-service grocery, medical, and dining within 10 minutes.
Home prices: $450K–$1.8M. Bluffside and Bay of Green Bay waterfront homes. Limited inventory — one of the smallest housing markets in Door County.
Who buys here: The most privacy-seeking buyer on the peninsula. Buyers who have toured Door County extensively and want maximum seclusion, minimal tourist traffic, and direct Newport State Park access. Year-round residents and serious vacation home buyers. Not a starter market — buyers typically know exactly why they want Ellison Bay specifically.
Inventory is limited. Contact Diane for current listings and off-market opportunities in Ellison Bay and northern Door County.
Or compare with all Door County waterfront villages.
If you want your next home to be a haven that's "away from it all" but with easy access to all Door County has to offer, Ellison Bay is worth exploring. Located at the northern tip of the peninsula, Ellison Bay is the antithesis of urban and suburban life — and the most deliberately secluded village in Door County. But stay awhile and you'll learn this tiny hamlet buzzes with its own quiet activity, culture, and tight-knit community.
What defines Ellison Bay above anything else is its proximity to Newport State Park — Wisconsin's only designated Dark Sky Preserve and one of the state's most pristine wilderness areas. At 2,373 acres, Newport offers 30 miles of trails, 11 miles of Lake Michigan shoreline, and night skies unmatched anywhere else in Wisconsin. For buyers who value nature access as much as waterfront views, no other Door County address delivers this combination.
| Village Comparison | Ellison Bay | Sister Bay (5 mi south) |
|---|---|---|
| Character | Most secluded, smallest village, nature-first | Most amenity-complete, busiest, year-round services |
| Price range | $450K–$1.8M | $300K–$2M+ |
| Inventory | Very limited — small housing stock | Higher inventory, more condo options |
| State park access | Newport State Park (Dark Sky Preserve) — adjacent | Peninsula State Park — 10 min drive south |
| Tourist traffic | Minimal — far fewer visitors than southern villages | High in summer — Door County's most visited village |
| Year-round services | Limited locally — 10 min to Sister Bay for full services | Full grocery, medical, dining year-round |
Life in Ellison Bay is deliberate. Residents choose this village because they want the most authentic, unhurried version of Door County living — and they're willing to accept limited local services to have it. The summer season brings visitors to Newport State Park but the village itself remains quiet. Winter reveals the full character of the community: small, self-sufficient, and deeply connected to the natural environment.
The Clearing Folk School, located on 128 acres of bluffside woodland, draws students from across the country for week-long courses in arts, crafts, and natural history — lending Ellison Bay a cultural depth unusual for a village of its size.
Ellison Bay students attend the Gibraltar Area School District — the same K–12 district serving Sister Bay, Fish Creek, and northern Door County. Small class sizes, strong community involvement, Gibraltar Area School is located in Fish Creek approximately 20 minutes south.
Ellison Bay is one of Door County's smallest and most constrained housing markets — limited developable land, small total housing stock, and a buyer pool that self-selects for privacy and Newport State Park proximity. This structural scarcity supports steady long-term appreciation. Properties range from $450K for inland and village homes to $1.8M+ for bluffside Bay of Green Bay waterfront positions. The market moves quickly for well-priced properties because qualified buyers who specifically want Ellison Bay are decisive — they've already done their Door County research. For current comparable sales data, contact Diane Taillon at Arbor Crowne Properties.
Single-family homes dominate — historic cottages, bluffside Bay of Green Bay properties, and woodland homes with Newport State Park trail access. Condos and multi-family units are essentially absent from Ellison Bay's housing stock; buyers seeking condos in northern Door County typically look at Sister Bay condos. The zip code is 54210. Properties in Ellison Bay tend to be larger lots with more land than comparable-priced properties in Fish Creek or Sister Bay — the trade-off for the distance from services is genuine space and privacy.
Newport State Park is Wisconsin's only designated Dark Sky Preserve — a 2,373-acre wilderness park with 11 miles of Lake Michigan shoreline and 30 miles of trails, located immediately adjacent to Ellison Bay. The Dark Sky designation means the area has some of the least light pollution in Wisconsin, making it one of the best stargazing locations in the Midwest. For buyers who value proximity to preserved natural land as a primary purchase criterion, no other Door County village offers a comparable park adjacency. Newport State Park access is the single feature that most consistently distinguishes Ellison Bay from every other village on the peninsula.
Ellison Bay is 5 miles north of Sister Bay via WI-42 — approximately 8 minutes by car. This proximity is important context for buyers concerned about Ellison Bay's limited local services: Sister Bay has a full-service grocery store, Aurora BayCare medical clinic, and the peninsula's broadest year-round dining and retail. Ellison Bay residents typically make a weekly or bi-weekly trip to Sister Bay for full-service needs, treating the village as a quiet residential base with easy access to amenities rather than a remote outpost.
188 people live in ELLISON BAY, where the median age is 62.2 and the average individual income is $45,113. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.
Total Population
Median Age
Population Density Population Density This is the number of people per square mile in a neighborhood.
Average individual Income
ELLISON BAY has 96 households, with an average household size of 1.96. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau. Here’s what the people living in ELLISON BAY do for work — and how long it takes them to get there. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.
Total Population
Population Density Population Density This is the number of people per square mile in a neighborhood.
Median Age
Men vs Women
Population by Age Group
0-9 Years
10-17 Years
18-24 Years
25-64 Years
65-74 Years
75+ Years
Education Level
Total Households
Average Household Size
Average individual Income
Households with Children
With Children:
Without Children:
Marital Status
Blue vs White Collar Workers
Blue Collar:
White Collar:
Arbor Crowne Properties specializes in luxury and waterfront Door County homes. Situated in the idyllic town of Ephraim and operating out of the historic Hillside Waterfront Hotel, Arbor Crowne is perfectly positioned to address your buying and selling needs.
